Janice Richard-Kamalu

The Superintendent did not prove by a preponderance of the evidence that the
Respondent impeded the Department's efforts to achieve its policy and goals and/or brought
discredit upon the Department when on or about February 9, 2010, while on the Medical
Roll, in a Stationary Recuperating Status, she removed snow from the sidewalks with the use
of a snow blower and/or shovel at or near her residence located at 8155 South Loomis Blvd.

The Superintendent did not prove by a preponderance of the evidence that the
Respondent impeded the Department's efforts to achieve its policy and goals and/or brought
discredit upon the Department when on or about February 10, 2010, while on the Medical
Roll, in a Stationary Recuperating Status, she removed snow from the sidewalks and/or the
alley with the use of a snow blower and/or shovel at or near her residence located at 8155
South Loomis Blvd.

On or about March 19, 2010, the Respondent provided a false written report to
Investigator Michael Cruz of the Medical Integrity Unit by stating that on February 9, 2010,
she "was not out of the house" and that "after the snow storm [she] heard a snow blower and
looked outside to see [her] neighbor snow blowing and thought what a wonderful thing
because [she] was sick. [She then] went back to bed," or words to that effect, when asked if
she was removing snow with a snow blower from the sidewalks located at 8155 South
Loomis at approximately 1127 hours while recuperating on medical stationary status.

On or about March 19, 2010, the Respondent provided a false written report to
Investigator Michael Cruz of the Medical Integrity Unit by stating that on February 10, 2010,
she "went to the Doctor then straight to the Medical Section," or words to that effect, when
asked if she was removing snow with a snow blower from sidewalks located at 8155 South
Loomis while recuperating on medical stationary status.

On or about March 30, 2010, during a statement given to Investigator Michael Cruz
of the Medical Integrity Unit, the Respondent stated that on February 10, 2010, she went to
the doctor at "around 10:00 a.m., when they opened, the exact time, [she was] not sure, [she]
was the first or second person there," or words to that effect, when in fact at approximately
0830 hours her vehicle was located outside her residence at 8155 South Loomis Blvd., and at
approximately 1125 hours she was observed leaving her residence and removing snow from
the sidewalks and/or the alley and/or a vehicle with the use of a snow blower and/or shovel at
or near her residence at 8155 South Loomis Blvd. before entering a vehicle and relocating to
the Department's Medical Section located at 3510 South Michigan Avenue at approximately
1227 hours.

The Superintendent did not prove by a preponderance of the evidence that the
Respondent violated General Order 98-02, Section III-F, when on or about February 9, 2010,
while on the Medical Roll, in a Stationary Recuperating Status, she removed snow from the
sidewalks with the use of a snow blower and/or shovel at or near her residence located at
8155 South Loomis Blvd.

The Superintendent did not prove by a preponderance of the evidence that the
Respondent violated General Order 98-02, Section III-F, when on or about February 10,
2010, while on the Medical Roll, in a Stationary Recuperating Status, she removed snow
from the sidewalks and/or the alley with the use of a snow blower and/or shovel at or near
her residence located at 8155 South Loomis Blvd.

On or about March 19, 2010, the Respondent provided a false written report to
Investigator Michael Cruz of the Medical Integrity Unit by stating that on February 9, 2010,
she "was not out of the house" and that "after the snow storm [she] heard a snow blower and
looked outside to see [her] neighbor snow blowing and thought what a wonderful thing
because [she] was sick. [She then] went back to bed," or words to that effect, when asked if
she was removing snow with a snow blower from sidewalks located at 8155 South Loomis at
approximately 1127 hours while recuperating on medical stationary status, thereby making a
false report, written or oral.

On or about March 19, 2010, the Respondent provided a false written report to
Investigator Michael Cruz of the Medical Integrity Unit by stating that on February 10, 2010,
she "went to the Doctor then straight to the Medical Section," or words to that effect, when
asked if she was removing snow with a snow blower from sidewalks located at 8155 South
Loomis while recuperating on medical stationary status, thereby making a false report,
written or oral.

On or about March 30, 2010, during a statement given to Investigator Michael
Cruz of the Medical Integrity Unit, the Respondent stated that on February 10, 2010, she
went to the doctor at "around 10:00 a.m., when they opened, the exact time, [she was] not
sure, [she] was the first or second person there," or words to that effect, when in fact at
approximately 0830 hours her vehicle was located outside her residence at 8155 South
Loomis Blvd., and at approximately 1125 hours she was observed leaving her residence and
removing snow from the sidewalks and/or the alley and/or a vehicle with the use of a snow
blower and/or shovel at or near her residence at 8155 South Loomis Blvd. before entering a
vehicle and relocating to the Department's Medical Section located at 3510 South Michigan
Avenue at approximately 1227 hours, thereby making a false report, written or oral.

The Superintendent did not prove by a preponderance of the evidence that the
Respondent failed to follow the Department's medical roll procedures when on or about
February 9, 2010, while on the Medical Roll, in a Stationary Recuperating Status, she
removed snow from the sidewalks with the use of a snow blower and/or shovel at or near her
residence located at 8155 South Loomis Blvd.

The Superintendent did not prove by a preponderance of the evidence that the
Respondent failed to follow the Department's medical roll procedures when on or about
February 10, 2010, while on the Medical Roll, in a Stationary Recuperating Status, she
removed snow from the sidewalks and/or the alley and/or a vehicle with the use of a snow
blower and/or shovel at or near her residence located at 8155 South Loomis Blvd.